Suit says city discriminates against handicapped
One could surmise that the city, with unlimited resources, is trying to stifle the opposition by drowning FOPS in legal bills.
The battle of the bike lanes continues, with a new front opened by an attorney for a nonprofit citizens’ group, and his office being vandalized, and not for the first time.
The attorney is George Bochetto, who has a habit of taking on city overreach, and usually winning.
In this case, he represents Friends of Pine and Spruce (FOPS), which organized in 2024 to fight the city’s insane law that prohibits even momentary stopping in bike lanes, and also in opposition to proposed barriers to be installed on bike lanes.
In a meeting last November, members were brought up to date on the continuing battle.
FOPS does not oppose bike lanes, per se, explains Lloyd Brotman, the group’s president. When bike lane installation began during the Michael Nutter administration, residents of Pine and Spruce were promised they would always have access to their front doors. And they did, as brief stopping to discharge or load passengers, or unload groceries, was permitted in bike lanes.
There were no complaints about the policy, other than from the voracious Bicycle Coalition of Greater Philadelphia, a small, effective lobby that is never satisfied about anything.
In his opening legal salvo, Bochetto argued that the city was acting without legal authority. The courts backed him up, suspending any work the city planned.
That case is still active. One element of the fight was highlighted in this column. The city is appealing the ruling.
Last week, Bochetto opened another front with a lawsuit alleging that the city’s prohibition of stopping in bike lanes violates the federal Americans with Disabilities Act.
Yes, he’s making a federal case out of it.
Prior to filing the suit, he shared it with the city, seeking a resolution to avoid a court fight.
There are compromises that can be made, he told me, but “they are not willing to sit down and resolve it. Are they robots over there? There is no consideration of alternatives.”
The city’s attitude, he said, was “startling and irresponsible.”
A request for comment was sent to the mayor’s office, which declined comment on an active lawsuit.
One could surmise that the city, with unlimited resources, is trying to stifle the opposition by drowning FOPS in legal bills.
FOPS has spent more than $100,000 so far, all raised from concerned citizens.
Why do it?
“Because we believe in the battle and believe it can be won,” said Brotman. “The facts are on our side. The facts will eventually neutralize and overrule the emotional response that has driven the . . . city plan.”
After Bochetto filed the suit, it was reported in the Monday Inquirer. That very night, before midnight, someone smashed several panes of glass on Bochetto’s Center City office (the former home of Frog, one of the restaurants that led Philadelphia’s restaurant renaissance in the 1970s). Coincidence? Hardly, thinks Bochetto, a Republican, who has been a burr under the saddle of Philly’s Woke and biking elite. His office also was vandalized after he won an injunction halting the city’s plans.
He also successfully sued the city to prevent Mayor Jim Kenney’s unlawful order to remove the Christopher Columbus statue from Marconi Plaza in South Philadelphia.
He was too late to prevent blockhead Kenney from unlawfully tearing down the statue of Frank Rizzo in front of the Municipal Services Building in Center City, but he took the city to court. He won an order that the city had to return the statue to its owners, and to pay for damage to the statue that occurred when it was clumsily removed in the dead of night. Bochetto also defeated Septa’s plan to reduce service for riders.
In the current suit, two handicapped individuals allege that the no-stop policy has a serious impact on them.
Incidentally, the Inquirer refers to the city’s plans as “safety upgrades,” when “changes” would be the more accurate term. But the Inquirer has criticized FOPS for exercising its right to fight City Hall.
An update on all legal action was explained at a meeting of FOPS Thursday night in Bochetto’s Center City law office. Some 60 people attended, and were angry at the city’s attitude.
Bochetto explained that a class action lawsuit had been filed on behalf of two Center City residents, Susan Hess Herskovitz and Carl J. Roeder, who are handicapped senior citizens.
The city law “contains no disability-specific exception.”
Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act demands “a city that shuts people with mobility disabilities out of a service must reasonably modify the rule that does it.”
In a statement, the pro-bike Philly Bike Action issued a statement saying the lawsuit “is nothing more than an attempt by a privileged group of neighbors to keep their parking spots.”
You will find less crap than that in a Taco Bell bathroom.
The issue has nothing to do with parking spots, which already are as rare as an Eagles second-half scoring drive. There is no group more privileged than bicycle riders, who pay no taxes, no licensing or registration fees, and get to park free everywhere. And yet they were awarded half of Pine and Spruce although only 2% of Philadelphians commute by bike.
The city heard about accessibility concerns during hearings, said Bochetto, but elected officials chose to go deaf.
The suit states that Disability Rights Pennsylvania, a watchdog nonprofit, asked the city in December to “retract and remove” the no-stopping ban, and to revise the plan to give people with disabilities free access to enter and leave their homes.
More information, including how to donate, is available at the FOPS website.
This column was updated at 8:22 a.m. on 11/20/26 to include bicycle commuter information.