The first and last word on amnesty

Donald J. Trump promised mass deportation of all illegals — not just the bad hombres as many with faulty memories say today.

Share
The first and last word on amnesty

When Democrats take control of the House and Senate in January, things will change because Democrats will control all the committees, and all the purse strings.

One thing you can bet on them changing is immigration policy, and I do not expect them to recreate Joe Biden’s insane open door policy.

Why?

Because the, yes, invasion, of maybe 14 million foreigners was wildly unpopular with Americans. The border and the economy were the two main planks in the platform of Donald J. Trump, who promised mass deportation of them all — not just the bad hombres as many with faulty memories say today.

At the time he made that promise, I made two points:

1- There was no way Trump could deport them all in four years. The U.S. had never deported as many as 1 million in a year.

2- Once Americans saw it, they would not like it. And that was before rogue elements of ICE created a U-turn in public opinion from a majority endorsing mass deportation to a majority opposing it.

That majority opens the door to a solution, and one might be amnesty, such as President Ronald Reagan agreed to in 1986. Some 3 million people were granted legal status.

Amnesty is a thorny bush, and there is an explainer following my comments.

Some solutions, which you might call Amnesty Lite, are not a blanket under which all illegal activity is completely forgiven. 

For instance, President Barack Obama offered a plan in 2013.

Republican Florida Congresswoman Maria Salazar submitted her ideas in 2025. 

And, not to brag, I have submitted a 5-point plan more than once. 

Since that may be locked behind a pay wall, I will summarize it here:

1. Seal our southern border with a barrier that can be a physical wall where necessary, but can include fencing, Border Patrol agents, cameras, motion detectors, drones, Komodo dragons if necessary.

2. Since jobs are a magnet, lock up employers who knowingly hire undocumented workers. Send CEOs to jail for a year and those jobs will dry up like peas in a rotisserie.

3. Implement a statute of limitations for those here at least five years who have a clean record. That's almost 90 percent of those here illegally.  In many states, after a certain number of years you can't be prosecuted for crimes such as arson, counterfeiting, fraud, even some sexual offenses. I'd add illegal entry to the list.

4. Allow people protected by that statute to come forward, be documented, and become legal residents. They pay whatever fines, taxes, and penalties owed. They submit to fingerprinting and biometrics to establish their identity.

5. Bar those who become legal residents from applying for citizenship, as punishment for breaking our laws.  Minor children they brought to this country with them would be eligible for citizenship, and children born here, of course, are citizens.

This is not  amnesty. It has penalties, but keeps families together while disrupting the avenues for illegal immigration.

Just and merciful.

—-


Now, following is an abridged version of the Inquirer’s explainer on what amnesty means, written by reporter Jeff Gammage, who specializes in covering immigration, without ever using the word illegal. Legal and illegal are all called "immigrants." Technically true, but obfuscating the reality, as is true in almost all legacy media. 

I have added my own commentary in italics.


What is amnesty?

Generally speaking, amnesty is an official act of forgiveness granted by a government to a group of people. It comes from the Greek word amnestia, meaning “forgetfulness,” in this case the forgetting of past violations. In immigration, amnesty would take the form of government-granted legal relief to allow undocumented people ― a few, some, or all ― to gain legal status.

So people who came to the U.S. without permission would be rewarded for violating federal law?

That is the GOP view, (it is not just the GOP view) and a big reason that amnesty proposals have struggled in Congress. It is important to note that individual circumstances vary widely. Some people were brought to the country as children, having had no say in where they went or lived. Others entered legally as adults, then overstayed visas. Some have tried for years to legalize their status but have no path to do so. (Despite the excuse-giving, all are here illegally.)

How many undocumented people live in the U.S.?

Millions. The Pew Research Center puts the figure at about 14 million, while the estimate of the Migration Policy Institute is even higher. That agency reported this year that the undocumented population reached 15.8 million in mid-2024. Both those figures are higher than the population of Pennsylvania, which is about 13 million.

Why not simply deport people who have no authority to be here?

The Trump administration is trying. But here’s where the machinery of deportation and the cry of “No amnesty!” bump against reality.

During the first 18 months of the president’s second term, Homeland Security completed about 980,000 deportations, according to an analysis by the Migration Policy Institute.

That works out to about 653,000 deportations a year.

Which means even if the government can keep up that fast pace, deporting the 14 million undocumented people who are already in the U.S. would take more than 21 years. And that does not account for the people who would be arriving even as others were being sent out. (Under President Trump, the number of those arriving has been cut to almost zero.)

Would amnesty have to cover all undocumented immigrants?

No. Multiple configurations could be conceived and implemented to cover smaller groups of people.

For instance, amnesty could be extended to immigrants who have lost temporary protected status, which the Trump administration has stripped or intends to take from nearly a million people, many of whom have lived here for decades. That loss of TPS exposes people to deportation.(TPS protection should be restored. They entered legally.)

Amnesty could also be offered to DACA recipients, people who were brought to the country as children and have lived under Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals. That program, which covers about 436,350 immigrants, has been in greater or lesser danger of elimination depending on which political party has held power. (DACA should be protected.)

Who would benefit from amnesty?

To undocumented people, the gain would be life-changing. No more living in fear that a routine traffic stop could forever separate them from their families ― who routinely include American sons and daughters. (Such separations are the result of the person’s illegal activity.) They would gain legal work authorization. 

The White House says amnesty would damage the country, exploding federal funding for programs such as SNAP and Medicaid as more people gained access to those benefits.

Has immigration amnesty been granted before?

Yes — by President Ronald Reagan, an architect of the modern conservative movement. He signed the 1986 Immigration Reform and Control Act, which granted legal status and a path to permanent residency to nearly three million undocumented immigrants, most of them Latino.

Today the word amnesty has become toxic to many Republicans in Congress (not just Republicans in Congress) and in the executive branch, as campaign promises of harsh enforcement helped sweep Trump to the Oval Office. Even some Democrats are queasy about calling amnesty what it is, preferring terms like reform.